|
Hello my friends, Today I wanted to reflect and process with you about the wounding our spirits can endure by witnessing and experiencing our faith being weaponized by those in power and the harm it causes in our world. Towards the end of today's newsletter, I provide some practical steps towards spiritual care that I have found really helpful and I hope you do as well. Recommended Resources: -When Religion Hurts You: Healing from Religious Trauma and the Impact of High-Control Religion by Laura E. Anderson. I continue to find this book immensely helpful and many people I have recommended it to have as well. If you are more of a listener, she has this avalable as an audiobook as well. -Sacred Wounds, Second Edition: Finding Your Path to Healing from Spiritual Trauma by Teresa Mateus. This second edition of Mateus' book specifically includes Christian nationalism and religious extremism more broadly. The season of Advent begins on November 29th! If you are looking for a daily devotional that provides daily scripture readings, reflections, and prayers to help make your journey towards Christmas in the world we are currently living in more meaningful, consider my devotional below.
When Christianity Wounds the SoulI want to begin with these words I wrote back in 2025: "There should be a name for this grief, the grief of watching the faith that raised you trade away its own soul. The grief of watching the church that taught you to love your neighbor, to care for the vulnerable, to seek justice and walk humbly with God, lay all of it down at the altar of political power. And then, as if that were not wounding enough, to watch that same faith turn on you, to call your grief a betrayal, to name your love disloyalty, to exile you for daring to hold onto what it once taught you to treasure. This is the grief of spiritual homelessness. This is the grief of seeing the place that promised to be a refuge become a marketplace of power and fear. The grief of being cast out by those who once called you family. The grief of watching those who taught you about integrity and character be silent in the face of injustice." Same Is True Today. For many Christians in the United States, this has become an increasingly familiar experience. We have and continue to watch Christian language, symbols, Scripture, and institutions being used to justify cruelty, elevate political power, excuse injustice, and diminish the dignity of our neighbors. We are watching people invoke the name of Jesus while advocating for things that seem to stand in direct opposition to the life and teachings of Jesus. And for those of us who take our faith seriously, this is not simply a political disagreement. It is a deeply spiritual experience. It can be disorienting to watch something that once gave you hope become associated with things that grieve you. It can be painful to hear the name of Jesus invoked to defend policies and actions that seem to contradict everything you understand about his compassion, his solidarity with the vulnerable, and his call to love our neighbors. Some people experience this as anger. Others experience it as sadness, confusion, anxiety, exhaustion, or even shame. Some find themselves questioning their place in the Christian community. Others struggle to reconcile the faith that has sustained them with the public expression of Christianity they increasingly see around them. I want to suggest that some of what we are experiencing is grief. And it deserves to be named as such. For many of us, Christianity is not simply a collection of beliefs. It is the language through which we learned to pray, the community in which we experienced belonging, the stories that gave meaning to our lives, and the person of Jesus who taught us what love looks like. When that same religious tradition is used to justify cruelty, exclusion, domination, or dehumanization, the resulting pain cannot only be difficult to articulate but difficult for others to understand. You might find yourself grieving the loss of trust in religious institutions. You might feel betrayed by people you once looked to for spiritual guidance. You might struggle to sing familiar worship songs or hear familiar passages of Scripture without remembering how those same words have been used to hurt people. You may even feel guilty for distancing yourself from certain Christian communities, traditions, or expressions of faith, as though acknowledging the harm means abandoning Christianity itself. But there is an important distinction here I think. Grieving the misuse of Christianity is not the same thing as grieving Christianity itself. In fact, sometimes that grief comes precisely because you love Jesus, care deeply about the church, and believe that the Christian faith is meant to bear witness to a radically different way of being human. A way of love, compassion, peace, and justice. There is nothing unfaithful about mourning the ways that witness has been distorted. This grief affects more than our spiritual lives. Human beings are not designed to remain indefinitely immersed in distress. Our bodies respond to perceived threats, even when those threats reach us through news reports, social media, public rhetoric, and the repeated witnessing of human suffering. We can experience disrupted sleep, chronic tension, headaches, fatigue, difficulty concentrating, irritability, anxiety, and a persistent sense of dread. I know I have. Psychologists sometimes use the language of moral injury to describe the distress that can arise when people witness, participate in, or feel betrayed by actions that violate deeply held moral convictions. Although the term has often been studied in military and other high-stakes settings, the broader experience of moral distress is relevant to understanding what happens when we repeatedly encounter violations of our deepest values. There is also something especially painful about experiencing this within a religious community. When the people, institutions, or traditions we associate with compassion and moral guidance become sources of betrayal or harm, it can disrupt our sense of safety and belonging. We may begin to question whether we can trust anyone. We may become hypervigilant, constantly watching for the next disturbing development. We may feel compelled to monitor every political announcement, every religious leader’s statement, and every new example of injustice because looking away feels like complicity. Eventually, even our moments of rest can become filled with guilt and pain. We can begin to feel that if we are not paying attention, speaking out, responding, or doing something, we are somehow failing the people who are suffering. But we are human beings, not inexhaustible instruments of resistance. Our bodies have limits. Our minds need rest. Our souls need care. Acknowledging those limits is not an abandonment of our moral responsibilities. It is an acknowledgment of our humanity. We are not the first generation to wrestle with this. There is an important historical dimension to this conversation, particularly given that Sunday, November 22nd, is known as “Christ The King Sunday” in Christian liturgical calendars throughout the globe. In 1925, Pope Pius XI issued the encyclical Quas Primas, establishing the Feast of Christ the King, which took place in 1926. A hundred years ago the very week this newsletter was published! The historical context behind Christ The King Sunday is deeply important for us to remember today. Europe was still living with the consequences of the First World War, and authoritarian nationalism, political extremism, and competing claims of ultimate allegiance were gaining influence. Pius XI argued that Christ’s authority could not be confined to private religious devotion. Christ was Lord over every dimension of human life, including public life and political power. Whatever our differences with the encyclical’s particular theological framework, its central claim offers an important question for Christians today: Who ultimately has our allegiance? History has shown us the dangers of religious institutions and Christian leaders lending spiritual legitimacy to authoritarian political movements. In Germany, the so-called German Christians movement sought to align Protestant Christianity with Nazi nationalism and racial ideology. In the United States, some prominent political and religious figures expressed admiration for fascist movements in Europe during the 1930s. These histories are not identical to our present circumstances, and historical comparisons should be made carefully. But they remind us that Christianity has not been immune to the temptation to exchange the way of Jesus for the promises of political power, national identity, and authoritarian control. Today, as elements of the Christian Nationalism seek to reshape American political and cultural life around a particular vision of Christian authority, we ned to continue to ask difficult questions about what happens when political allegiance begins to take precedence over the teachings and character of Jesus. This is not a warning against Christians participating in public life. Christians should care about their neighbors, advocate for justice, protect human dignity, and participate in the common good. The problem is not public faith. The problem is when political power becomes the organizing center of our faith rather than the person and way of Jesus. I believe that is the upside down meaning behind calling Jesus our king. It is not to seek power over others, but speak truth to power for and with them. What do we do with all this grief? I don’t think the answer is to become less compassionate, less informed, or less concerned about the suffering of others. Nor do I think the answer is to pretend that everything is fine. Instead, I think we need to recover some practices of spiritual care that help us remain faithful without allowing the cruelty we witness to consume our entire lives. I want to mention a few that have really helped me. First, give yourself permission to grieve. You do not have to immediately turn every painful experience into a lesson, a theological explanation, or an opportunity for activism. Sometimes the faithful response is simply to acknowledge that something is wrong and that it hurts. The biblical tradition gives us an entire language for this. The Psalms are filled with grief, lament, anger, confusion, and questions directed toward God. The prophets wept over injustice. Jesus himself wept at the tomb of Lazarus. Lament is not a failure of faith. It is one of the ways faith tells the truth about suffering while refusing to surrender hope. Second, establish boundaries around your exposure to distress. You can care deeply about what is happening in the world without consuming every piece of news, every social media argument, or every disturbing video. Consider setting intentional times to engage with the news rather than allowing it to occupy every available moment. Give yourself permission to step away from conversations that are no longer constructive. Turn off notifications. Protect time when your attention belongs to your family, your friendships, your worship, and your own well-being. Being informed is important. Being perpetually overwhelmed is not a moral obligation. Third, reconnect with the physical world around you. When so much of our distress comes through screens, it can be healing to return to the tangible world. Go outside. Take a walk. Sit beneath a tree. Work in a garden. Share a meal with someone you love. Pay attention to the ordinary goodness of being alive. Christian spirituality has always affirmed the goodness of physical creation. We worship a God who became flesh, entered the material world, and shared the ordinary experiences of human life. Our bodies are not obstacles to our spiritual lives. They are part of the lives God loves. Sometimes caring for our souls begins with remembering that we are embodied creatures who need sunlight, movement, nourishment, sleep, and human companionship. Fourth, seek out communities where your faith can breathe. You need people with whom you can be honest. People who will not dismiss your grief, shame your questions, or demand that you defend the indefensible. Find communities where compassion is practiced, where differences can be held with humility, where the vulnerable are treated with dignity, and where the teachings of Jesus are taken seriously. You do not have to carry this alone. And if the distress becomes persistent or begins interfering with your ability to function, seeking support from a qualified mental health professional is not a failure of faith. It is a wise and courageous act of faith and care. Finally, remember that faithfulness does not require you to carry the entire world. There is a difference between being responsible for the good you can do and believing that you are personally responsible for preventing every evil you witness. You can speak when you need to speak. You can show up when someone needs you. You can advocate for those being harmed. You can offer your time, resources, and presence. But you are also allowed to rest. You are allowed to experience joy. You are allowed to celebrate your children, enjoy your friendships, laugh with your neighbors, and appreciate the beauty of an ordinary afternoon. None of these things makes you less committed to justice. In fact, they may help sustain the compassion that makes your commitment possible. Christ is still King So, as we think about all of this through the lens of Christ the King Sunday, I keep returning to the central Christian confession that Jesus is Lord. Not Caesar. Not a political party. Not a nation. Not a movement. Not a president. Not a religious institution. Jesus. And the Jesus we encounter in the Gospels does not establish his kingdom through domination, humiliation, coercion, or the dehumanization of his enemies. He kneels to wash feet. He welcomes those pushed to the margins. He touches people others consider untouchable. He feeds the hungry. He confronts religious hypocrisy. He identifies himself with the vulnerable. He refuses the temptation to seize political power through violence. His kingdom is not made visible by how effectively Christians can control other people. It is made visible through the presence of love, mercy, justice, humility, and self-giving service. This does not mean that we should stop resisting injustice or speaking against the ways Christianity is being weaponized. It means that our resistance must also reflect the character of the One whose name we bear. We cannot allow the cruelty we oppose to determine the kind of people we become. I know that some of you are tired. Some of you are grieving the loss of religious communities you once called home. Some of you are trying to figure out how to remain Christian when so much of what is being done in the name of Christianity feels unrecognizable to you. I want you to know that you are not alone in that struggle. And I want you to remember that you do not have to abandon Jesus because other people have misrepresented him. You do not have to surrender your faith to those who have confused Christian identity with political power. You do not have to sacrifice your mental, emotional, and physical well-being to prove that you care. There is still a way of following Jesus that makes room for tenderness, courage, humility, solidarity, and hope. There is still a way of being Christian that refuses to make enemies of our neighbors. There is still a way of practicing our faith that looks more like a foot washing than a political rally, more like a shared table than a fortress, and more like the self-giving love of Jesus than the pursuit of power. Perhaps this is part of what we need to recover in this moment. Not a Christianity that demands more of our exhaustion, but a faith that leads us back to the life-giving presence of Jesus. Not a faith that teaches us to look away from suffering, but one that gives us the strength to remain compassionate without being consumed by it. A faith that doesn’t ask us to place our hope in the people who claim to speak for Jesus, but one that continually invites us to return to Jesus himself. Christ is King. And that means no earthly power gets the final word. May we find the courage to live as though that is true. And may we find the grace to care for one another along the way. Prayer Jesus, where do we bring this sorrow? Where do we take a grief with no name? We bring it to You. The One who was also abandoned, The One betrayed with a kiss, The One who wept over Jerusalem when it no longer recognized the things that make for peace. Hold us in this nameless grief. Remind us that You are still faithful even when Your church is not. Gather up the exiles, bind up the abandoned, and teach us again how to walk in love. Until the day the church remembers its first love, if it ever comes, may our lament become our prayer: Lord, have mercy. Christ, have mercy.
|
I have spent the majority of my life in Evangelical Christian spaces. I have experienced a lot of church hurt. I now write to explore topics that often are at the intersection of politics and Christianity. My desire is to discover how we can move away from Christian nationalism, religious fundamentalism, and church hurt to reclaim the Gospel of Jesus together. I'm glad you're here to join the conversation. I look forward to talking with you.
Hello my friends, With the Anti-Muslim rhetoric surging yet again in our country, I thought it might be helpful to process it together and ponder some ways of responding to it as we move forward. In that spirit, I have provided some resources as well as some real world examples towards the end of today's newsletter that you might find helpful in your conversations on this topic with others. Recommended Resources -Unsettling Truths: The Ongoing, Dehumanizing Legacy of the Doctrine of Discovery...
Hello my friends, Today, I just wanted to reflect on some of the angry sentiments I heard from some pastors and Christian influencers after the midterms and the opportunity I believe we Christians in America have collectively moving forward. Recommended Resources: -White Evangelical Support for Republicans Ticked Up Despite Blue Tsunami. I was heartbroken by this news, but not surprised. Even after everything that has happened, white Evangelical Christian support for the MAGA movement still...
There are so many things to celebrate in the United States today. So many historic firsts. For the first time in American history, more than 100 democratic women are serving alongside each other in the House of Representatives. We saw so many women, including many women of color, indigenous women, and Palestinian women be elected to both state and federal elections. We saw James Talarico flip Texas for the first time in over 30 years. We saw Abdul El-Sayed become the first Muslim elected to...